If you’re planning a food trip across Georgia or you’re just craving a good slice, the state actually has a surprisingly rich pizza scene. From wood-fired Neapolitan pies to classic foldable New York slices, Georgia has something for every pizza lover — and 2025 is shaping up to be a great year to explore what local chefs are creating. Below are my top 15 picks based on recent reviews, local buzz, food awards, and actual customer experiences. I also added links so you can easily check out menus, hours, and locations.
1. Antico Pizza Napoletana — Atlanta
Let’s be honest — if you ask anyone in Atlanta about the best pizza in the city (or even the state), Antico Pizza Napoletana usually comes up first. Their setup is simple: a blazing-hot wood-fired oven, San Marzano tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, and a crust that isn’t trying to be anything other than genuinely Italian.
Why people love it
The pies cook in under 90 seconds, giving you that signature char and soft, chewy crust.
The menu is small, but every pizza feels perfected.
The dining experience is casual but energetic — you often see groups sitting together at communal tables.
What to order
Margherita D.O.P
San Gennaro (sweet peppers + sausage)
- Best for: Authentic Neapolitan-style pizza
2. Piccola New York Pizza — Atlanta Area
If you’ve ever lived in New York and miss the giant foldable slices, this is the place people recommend. Piccola New York Pizza has been topping diner-based rankings for Atlanta, and it’s easy to see why: crispy crust, rich sauce, and lots of cheese — no overcomplicated experiments.
Why it stands out
Consistently high local ratings
Affordable compared to many “artisan” pizza places
Great for quick lunch or a casual dinner
What to get
Classic Cheese Slice
Pepperoni or Supreme Pie (if you’re going with a group)
- Best for: Classic New York–style slices
3. Fellini’s Pizza — Atlanta (Multiple Locations)
Fellini’s is one of those places that almost every Atlanta resident has a memory attached to. Open since the 1980s, it combines casual dining with a warm and slightly nostalgic vibe. If you want something simple, hearty, and not overly fancy — this is the spot.
Why locals keep going back
Big slices and generous toppings
Affordable prices
Family-friendly and great late-night stops
What to order
White Pizza
Fellini’s Special
- Best for: Longtime local favorite
4. JenChan’s — Atlanta (Southeast Area)
JenChan’s is one of the newest favorites on the list. It’s not your typical pizza restaurant — they mix in unique fusion elements that make their pies super memorable. If you like trying new flavor combinations, put this place on your list.
What makes it different
Asian-influenced flavors
Great drink pairings
Moderate pricing compared to gourmet pizza restaurants
Recommended dishes
Specialty fusion pies
Seasonal rotating flavors
- Best for: Creative and fusion-style pizzas
5. Your Pie — Athens & Across Georgia
If you’re traveling with friends or family who all want different toppings, Your Pie is a lifesaver. It’s fast-casual, affordable, and lets you build a custom 10-inch pizza exactly how you like it. Plus, it’s one of the few pizza chains that actually started in Georgia.
Why it’s worth visiting
Fully customizable pies
Brick oven baking
Good for groups, kids, and quick meals
Try these
Pesto Build-Your-Own Pizza
Nana’s Pie (house favorite)
- Best for: Fast, customizable build-your-own pizzas
6. Vinnie Van Go-Go’s — Savannah
If you’re exploring historic Savannah and your stomach starts rumbling, Vinnie Van Go-Go’s is one of the most popular stops for pizza lovers. It’s known for its massive slices, thin crust, and street-style atmosphere that fits the city perfectly.
Why people love it
Giant slices bigger than your hand
Outdoor seating in the heart of City Market
Affordable and perfect for tourists
What to order
Slice of Pepperoni (trust me, one slice is almost a full meal)
Garlic Spinach Pie
- Best for: Huge slices & true East Coast vibes
- Website: www.savannahcitymarket.com
7. O4W Pizza — Duluth
O4W Pizza (Old Fourth Ward) moved from Atlanta to Duluth — and the move boosted its popularity even more. The star of the menu is their iconic “Grandma Pie”, arguably one of the best pan-style pizzas in the state.
Why it stands out
Famous Detroit-style thick crust
Crispy edges with soft, airy center
Consistently high reviews
What to order
Grandma Pie (their signature)
Margherita Pan Pizza
- Best for: Award-winning Detroit-style pies
- Website: www.o4wpizza.com
8. Mellow Mushroom — Multiple Cities
Although it’s a well-known chain, Mellow Mushroom started in Atlanta — and its Georgia locations still feel very local. The pizzas here are fun, a little funky, and great for people who want something more creative than the classic pepperoni slice.
Why people go
Flavorful, stone-baked crust
Unique topping combinations
Fun and colorful interior design
What to order
Holy Shiitake Pie
Kosmic Karma
- Best for: Gourmet-style creative toppings
- Website: mellowmushroom.com
9. Blue Moon Pizza — Sandy Springs, Marietta, Smyrna
Blue Moon Pizza is the kind of place that becomes your regular spot. It’s not trying too hard to be fancy — just consistently good pizza, friendly staff, and a neighborhood atmosphere that makes you want to come back.
Why it’s popular
Great customer service
Family-friendly
Good mix of classic and specialty pies
What to order
Blue Moon Special
The Luau (if you like pineapple)
- Best for: Consistent everyday pizza & great service
- Website: https://bluemoonpizza.com
10. Oz Pizza — Fairburn & East Point
If you prefer supporting community-based restaurants instead of big franchises, Oz Pizza is a great pick. It’s well-loved in the South Atlanta suburbs and has that classic small-town warmth.
Why locals love it
Fresh dough & flavorful sauce
Good place for group dinners
Affordable combos
What to order
Veggie Supreme
Classic Pepperoni Pie
- Best for: Local, community-loved pizza
- Website: https://www.ozpizza.net
11. Joe’s New York Pizza — Johns Creek
If you want true New York–style pizza without driving into the busy parts of Atlanta, Joe’s New York Pizza in Johns Creek is a dependable choice. Their slices are large, thin, and foldable — exactly how a real NYC slice should be.
Why people love it
Authentic New York crust
Fresh cheese and flavorful sauce
Loved by families and students
What to order
Classic Cheese Pizza
Meat Lover’s Pie
- Best for: Big NYC slices in the suburbs
12. Billy’s Pizza — Gainesville
Located in Gainesville, Billy’s Pizza is a local favorite known for friendly service and generously topped pies. It’s one of those places where you instantly feel welcome.
Why it stands out
Warm, small-town vibe
Thick, satisfying crust
Great stop after exploring North Georgia
Must try
Billy’s Special
Hawaiian Pizza
- Best for: Local, homemade-style pies
13. Partners II Pizza — Peachtree City
Partners II Pizza has been around for years and has built a loyal customer base in Peachtree City. It’s especially popular with families because of its relaxed dining setup and wide variety of toppings.
Why locals recommend it
Friendly service
Customizable pies
Long-standing community favorite
What to order
House Special
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
14. Corner Pizza — Roswell
Roswell’s Corner Pizza delivers a balance of gourmet toppings and classic preparation. It’s a great date-night spot or a nice dinner option if you want pizza with a slightly elevated feel.
Why it’s worth visiting
Smooth, flavorful sauce
Fresh toppings
Indoor + patio seating
Best picks
Margherita
BBQ Chicken Pizza
- Best for: Cozy atmosphere & quality ingredients
15. Uncle Maddio’s Pizza — Georgia Locations
If you’re looking for something customizable and lighter, Uncle Maddio’s offers build-your-own pizzas, gluten-free crusts, and fresh veggie toppings — perfect for people who want more control over ingredients.
Why people visit
Quick service
Healthy topping choices
Perfect for lunch or early dinner
Recommended
Custom Veggie Pie
Steak & Blue Pizza
- Best for: Build-your-own pizzas with healthier options
- Website: unclemaddios.com
Final Thoughts
Georgia may not be the first place people think of when it comes to amazing pizza, but the state truly delivers a wide range of flavors and styles. From classic New York slices and crispy Detroit-style pans to wood-fired Neapolitan pies and creative fusion toppings, there’s a pizza place here for every craving. Whether you’re a local exploring new spots, a traveler passing through, or a true pizza lover chasing the next great slice, these restaurants offer something memorable. Try a few of them, explore different neighborhoods, and you might just find your new go-to pizza stop in Georgia.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the most popular pizza style in Georgia?
New York–style slices and Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas are the most popular across the state. However, Detroit-style pies and customizable fast-casual pizzas have also grown in popularity in recent years.
2. Are these pizza places family-friendly?
Yes. Most of the restaurants on this list — including Fellini’s, Your Pie, Blue Moon Pizza, Partners II Pizza, and Uncle Maddio’s — are great for families, groups, and casual dining.
3. Which pizza place is best for a quick bite?
Your Pie, Uncle Maddio’s, and Piccola New York Pizza are excellent for fast service if you’re in a hurry or want something easy for takeout.
4. Do any of these pizza spots offer vegan or gluten-free options?
A few do. Your Pie and Uncle Maddio’s offer gluten-free crusts and plant-based toppings. Some locations of Mellow Mushroom also have vegan cheese options.
5. What’s the best time to visit these pizza places to avoid long lines?
Weekdays before 6 PM are usually the easiest times. Popular spots like Antico Pizza and Fellini’s get very busy on weekends, so visiting early is recommended if you want the best dine-in experience.
