When it comes to pizza, Pennsylvania is truly underrated. From old-school Philly pizzerias to small-town gems baking crispy, wood-fired pies, this state has something for every pizza lover. After exploring reviews, local recommendations, and my own foodie notes, here are 15 of the absolute best pizza places in Pennsylvania you should try in 2025.
1. Pizzeria Beddia – Philadelphia
If you ask any Philly local about the best pizza in town, most will mention Pizzeria Beddia. Founded by Joe Beddia, this spot is known for its perfectly blistered crust, simple toppings, and old-school charm. The dough is fermented for over 24 hours, and every ingredient is carefully sourced.
Their tomato pie is legendary — crispy, light, and full of deep tomato flavor. There’s also a unique experience called the Hoagie Room, where you can book a two-hour tasting that includes hoagies, pizzas, and soft-serve dessert.
Tip: Reservations can be tricky, so book early through their site or on Resy.
Consistently rated among the best pizzas in the U.S.
Simple menu but flawless execution
Cozy, minimalist vibe
- Address: 1313 N Lee St, Philadelphia, PA
- Website: pizzeriabeddia.com
2. Mezzaluna Wood Fired Pizza – Kennett Square
Originally a popular food truck, Mezzaluna turned into a full-time restaurant and quickly became a local favorite. They specialize in wood-fired pies with both New York and Detroit-style options. Their “non-traditional” pizzas even won 3rd place at the International Pizza Expo — no small feat!
Their crust is slightly chewy, perfectly charred, and topped with creative combinations like roasted mushrooms, spicy honey, and ricotta.
Wood-fired oven for authentic flavor
Family-run and community-focused
BYOB (so bring your favorite wine!)
- Perfect order: Try the “Truffle Mushroom” or “Sweet Heat” pie — both are favorites.
- Address: 216 S Mill Rd, Kennett Square, PA
- Website: mezzalunawoodfiredpizza.com
3. Spuntino Wood Fired Pizzeria – Doylestown
In the heart of Doylestown, Spuntino serves authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas baked in a 900-degree wood-fired oven. The crust is thin and bubbly, with just the right balance of char and chew. According to The Washington Post and local reports, Spuntino was ranked #1 in Pennsylvania for Neapolitan pizza in 2025.
The owners are passionate about keeping things authentic — they use imported Italian flour, San Marzano tomatoes, and fresh mozzarella.
Authentic Neapolitan technique
Friendly atmosphere with great service
Consistently high local ratings
- Must-try: The “Regina Margherita” — simple but unforgettable.
- Address: 22 S Main St, Doylestown, PA
- Website: spuntinowoodfiredpizzeria.com
4. San Lucas Pizzeria – Philadelphia
San Lucas might not look fancy from the outside, but inside you’ll find one of Philly’s most beloved neighborhood pizza joints. It’s been featured by The New York Times as one of the 22 best pizzerias in America.
Their pizzas are classic and comforting — gooey cheese, crisp edges, and perfectly seasoned sauce. They keep it simple, and that’s what makes it so good.
True neighborhood pizzeria feel
Recognized nationally for quality
Great value for the price
- Top pick: Their classic pepperoni or plain cheese pie — traditional and timeless.
- Address: 2000 S Bouvier St, Philadelphia, PA
- Info: San Lucas Pizzeria on Wikipedia
5. Select Pizza & Grill – Warrington
If you want a more casual, family-friendly pizza experience, Select Pizza & Grill is a great pick. Known for their brick-oven crust and large variety of toppings, they’ve been ranked among the top 5 pizza places in Pennsylvania by local food outlets.
The menu offers everything from stuffed steak pizza to roasted veggie and BBQ chicken. Portions are generous, service is fast, and the atmosphere is relaxed — perfect for a casual dinner or take-out night.
Great for groups and families
Consistent flavor and quality
Variety beyond pizza (pasta, wings, salads)
- Location: Multiple locations across PA
- Info: Select Pizza & Grill – Warrington
6. Slice on Broadway – Pittsburgh
If you’re in Pittsburgh and love a good New York–style slice, Slice on Broadway is a must-visit. They serve large, foldable slices with a perfect balance of crispy crust and melty cheese.
In 2025, they made headlines for winning “World’s Best Cheese Slice” at the International Pizza Expo — which says a lot about their quality. The shop started small in Beechview but now has multiple locations across Pittsburgh, all keeping the same community feel and fresh flavor.
Thin, classic New York–style pizza done right
Fresh dough and house-made sauce daily
Friendly service and local community vibes
- Try this: Their award-winning plain cheese slice or the Green Monster (a pesto-based favorite).
- Locations: Beechview, East Liberty, Robinson, South Side, Wexford
- Website: sliceonbroadway.com
7. Vincent’s Pizza Park – Forest Hills (Pittsburgh)
Vincent’s Pizza Park is a Pittsburgh legend. It’s been around for decades and still serves up old-school pies baked in their original ovens. Locals know it as “Vinnie’s,” and the place has that nostalgic, friendly diner vibe where everyone knows your name.
Their signature “Vinnie Pie” is loaded with cheese, sauce, and toppings that stretch right to the edge. It’s not fancy, but it’s the kind of pizza that hits every comfort-food craving.
Iconic local history and loyal following
Generous toppings and hearty crust
Family-friendly and authentic
- Try this: Go for the Vinnie Special — it’s piled high with pepperoni, sausage, and mushrooms.
- Address: 998 Ardmore Blvd, Forest Hills, PA
- Info: Vincent’s Pizza Park (Wikipedia)
8. Leone’s Pizza – Oakmont
Tucked away in Oakmont, Leone’s Pizza is known for its Chicago-style deep-dish pizzas, a rare find in Pennsylvania. Their pies have thick, buttery crusts, rich tomato sauce, and layers of gooey cheese that stay hot until the last bite.
Besides pizza, they also serve hoagies, calzones, wings, and other Italian-American favorites. The restaurant has a cozy, family-run feel — the kind of place where you’ll see regulars chatting with staff like old friends.
Authentic Chicago-style deep-dish
Generous portions and fair prices
Great for dine-in or takeout nights
- Try this: Their Deep-Dish Deluxe — a perfect mix of sausage, onions, and green peppers.
- Address: 608 Allegheny River Blvd, Oakmont, PA
- Website: leonesrestaurant.com
9. New Columbus Pizza Co. – Pittston
If you’re looking for a true hidden gem, head to New Columbus Pizza Co. in Pittston. This small-town pizzeria gained national attention when it won “Best of the Best” at the International Pizza Challenge — a massive competition featuring top pizza makers from around the world.
Their pizzas are perfectly balanced — crispy on the outside, soft inside, and loaded with flavor. Whether you go for a classic Margherita or a creative seasonal special, everything feels crafted with care.
Award-winning, small-town charm
Hand-stretched dough and house-made sauces
Warm, welcoming staff
- Try this: Their Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza — it’s a local favorite.
- Location: Pittston, Luzerne County, PA
- Info: Patch News Report
10. Arcaro & Genell – Old Forge
No Pennsylvania pizza list is complete without mentioning Old Forge, known as the “Pizza Capital of the World.” The style here is unique — pizzas are called “trays,” not pies, and slices are “cuts.” The crust is thick and soft, topped with a slightly sweet sauce and a blend of cheeses (often mozzarella and American).
Arcaro & Genell is one of the most famous Old Forge pizzerias, and for good reason. It’s family-run, cozy, and full of tradition. Locals swear by their classic red tray, which tastes exactly the same as it did decades ago.
Signature “Old Forge-style” pizza you can’t find anywhere else
Deep local roots and old-fashioned recipes
Friendly small-town atmosphere
- Try this: The Red Tray — it’s the true Old Forge experience.
- Address: 443 S Main St, Old Forge, PA
11. Driftwood Oven – Pittsburgh
If you love pizza made with real care, Driftwood Oven is a must-visit. They started out as a mobile wood-fired oven and are now one of Pittsburgh’s most beloved pizza shops. Their dough is naturally fermented sourdough, giving each bite a light, airy texture and a hint of tang.
The pizzas come out perfectly blistered from the oven, with slightly charred edges and simple, flavorful toppings — everything from fresh basil to locally sourced sausage.
Naturally fermented sourdough crust
Seasonal and locally sourced ingredients
Cozy, neighborhood atmosphere
- Try this: The Margherita or their rotating “Special Pie of the Week.”
- Address: 3615 Butler St, Lawrenceville, Pittsburgh, PA
- Website: driftwoodoven.com
12. Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room – Pittsburgh
If you want pizza with a touch of sophistication, Proper Brick Oven & Tap Room is the place. The pizzas are baked in an 800-degree wood-fired oven, creating a slightly smoky, crisp crust that’s soft on the inside.
They’re known for creative flavors — like the Black & Gold, a nod to Pittsburgh’s colors, with roasted Yukon potatoes, rosemary, and garlic. Pair your pizza with one of their many craft beers on tap for the perfect night out.
Handcrafted, wood-fired pizzas
Fresh, high-quality ingredients
Great beer selection and modern vibe
- Try this: The Calabrian Pizza — it’s spicy, rich, and unforgettable.
- Address: 139 7th St, Pittsburgh, PA
- Website: properpgh.com
13. Tacconelli’s Pizzeria – Philadelphia
You can’t talk about Pennsylvania pizza without mentioning Tacconelli’s. It’s one of Philadelphia’s oldest and most iconic pizzerias, family-run for generations. They’re famous for their brick-oven tomato pies, made fresh with just the right amount of cheese and a sauce that’s bright, rich, and a little sweet.
One fun detail: you actually need to “reserve your dough” before visiting — that’s how popular they are!
True old-school tomato pies
Family tradition since the 1940s
Crispy, thin crust with rich tomato flavor
- Try this: Their Plain Tomato Pie — it’s legendary for a reason.
- Address: 2604 E Somerset St, Philadelphia, PA
- Website: tacconellipizza.com
14. Vinnie’s Pizza – Troy
Small-town charm meets big pizza flavor at Vinnie’s Pizza in Troy. It’s the kind of local spot where everyone knows your name, and the pizza always comes out piping hot with that classic homemade taste.
Their crust is soft with a light crunch, and the sauce leans slightly sweet, balanced perfectly with gooey cheese. Locals say it tastes like “real Italian home cooking.”
Cozy, family-owned pizzeria
Great value and generous toppings
Authentic, no-frills flavor
- Try this: The Deluxe Pizza — loaded with pepperoni, sausage, onions, and green peppers.
- Address: 52 Canton St, Troy, PA
- Info: Family Destinations Guide – Legendary Pizzerias
15. Scicchitano’s Pizzeria – Berwick
Scicchitano’s Pizzeria is a Berwick favorite that’s been serving up comfort food for decades. It’s a family-run spot with that classic small-town diner energy — friendly staff, simple menu, and pizza that’s always done right.
Their crust is perfectly balanced — chewy on the inside, crisp on the outside — and their sauce has that perfect tangy-sweet flavor that keeps people coming back.
Why people love it:
Consistent, delicious pizza every time
Local family tradition
Fresh ingredients and a nostalgic vibe
- Try this: The Pepperoni & Cheese Combo — classic, simple, and loved by everyone.
- Address: 701 W Front St, Berwick, PA
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re in the heart of Philadelphia, exploring the streets of Pittsburgh, or passing through small towns like Troy or Berwick, these pizzerias prove that Pennsylvania takes its pizza seriously.
Each of these places adds something different — from artisan sourdough to old-school tomato pies — and that’s exactly what makes PA such a great state for food lovers.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What is the most famous pizza place in Pennsylvania?
Old Forge is often called the “Pizza Capital of the World”, and Arcaro & Genell is one of its most iconic spots.
2. Where can I find the best New York–style pizza in Pennsylvania?
Check out Slice on Broadway in Pittsburgh — their thin, foldable slices are perfect for NY-style lovers.
3. Which city in Pennsylvania has the best pizza variety?
Pittsburgh offers the best mix — from sourdough crusts at Driftwood Oven to wood-fired pies at Proper Brick Oven.
4. What’s special about Old Forge–style pizza?
It’s a square “tray” of pizza with a thick, soft crust, sweet sauce, and a unique cheese blend — totally different from typical slices.
5. Are there any award-winning pizzerias in Pennsylvania?
Yes! New Columbus Pizza Co. in Pittston and Slice on Broadway in Pittsburgh have both won international awards for their pizza.
