Ohio might be known for its football and friendly small towns, but locals will tell you—our pizza game is seriously underrated. From crispy Columbus-style squares to wood-fired artisan pies, the Buckeye State has something for every pizza lover. Whether you’re a local looking for your next go-to spot or a traveler passing through, here are the 15 best pizza places in Ohio for 2025, ranked by taste, popularity, and local love.
1. Terita’s Pizza — Columbus
If you’ve ever talked to a Columbus local about pizza, chances are they’ve mentioned Terita’s Pizza at least once. This family-owned gem has been serving thin-crust, square-cut pies since 1959 — and it’s still one of the most beloved pizzerias in the state.
Their dough and sauce are made fresh every single day.
It’s classic Columbus-style: thin, crispy crust with toppings that go right to the edge.
They don’t skimp on pepperoni — every bite counts.
The Pepperoni Deluxe (a local favorite).
The Terita’s Special — loaded with sausage, green peppers, and mushrooms.
- Good to know: They’re carry-out only, so call ahead or order early. If you’re traveling through Columbus, it’s worth planning a detour for this one.
- Address: 3905 Cleveland Ave, Columbus, OH
- Website: teritas.com
2. Old Scratch Pizza — Dayton / Troy
Wood-fired pizza done right — that’s the promise at Old Scratch Pizza. With multiple locations around Dayton and Troy, they’ve built a reputation for Neapolitan-inspired pies with bold Midwest flavors.
They use Italian-style wood-fired ovens that give each crust a perfect char.
Locally sourced ingredients and creative toppings like “The Angry Beekeeper” (spicy soppressata, crushed red pepper, and hot honey).
Laid-back, family-friendly atmosphere with a great craft beer list.
“The Angry Beekeeper” if you like a little heat.
“The Margherita” for a fresh, authentic experience.
- Tip: Their Dayton location is super close to several local breweries — the perfect stop on a Saturday night.
- Address: 812 S Patterson Blvd, Dayton, OH
- Website: oldscratchpizza.com
3. DeCheco’s Pizzeria — Akron
Up in the Akron area, DeCheco’s Pizzeria has earned a loyal following thanks to its famous white sauce pizza. It’s family-owned, cozy, and proudly local — everything you want in a hometown favorite.
Their white sauce base is rich, creamy, and totally unique.
They use fresh, local ingredients and prepare each pizza to order.
It’s been a community staple since 1993.
The White Sauce Pizza (tomatoes, banana peppers, olives, basil — truly one of a kind).
Their Build-Your-Own option if you’re craving something customized.
- Tip: Pair your pizza with one of their dessert options from a local creamery — a perfect Ohio combo.
- Address: 2283 W Market St, Akron, OH
- Website: dechecospizzeria.com
4. Pizza Cottage — Buckeye Lake
If you’re planning a summer trip to Buckeye Lake or passing through central Ohio, you can’t skip Pizza Cottage. What started as a small local shop has grown into one of Ohio’s most recognizable pizzerias — without losing its friendly, small-town charm.
They’ve been ranked among the top independent pizzerias in the U.S. by Pizza Today®.
Known for their fun specialty pizzas — like the BLT Pizza or Chicken Bacon Ranch.
They’re deeply involved in community fundraisers, which locals love supporting.
The BLT Pizza (yes, it’s exactly what it sounds like).
The Cauliflower Crust for a lighter option.
- Tip: After your meal, take a short stroll around Buckeye Lake — perfect for sunset views and lakeside photos.
- Address: 4592 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH
Website: pizza-cottage.com
5. Sexton’s Pizza — Columbus
For a slightly more modern take on Ohio pizza, Sexton’s Pizza delivers big flavor and style. Their motto is “Quality Over Quantity,” and it shows in every slice. They’re known for their two-day dough fermentation and perfectly charred crust.
Dough is hand-tossed and stone-baked to crispy perfection.
They focus on local ingredients and unique recipes.
Several locations around Columbus make it convenient for visitors.
The Classic Pepperoni with their signature charred crust.
The Candied Bacon Pizza — sweet, smoky, and unforgettable.
- Tip: If you’re in Columbus for the weekend, grab a pie and walk to a nearby craft brewery. It’s a great local pairing.
- Address: 360 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH
- Website: sextonspizza.com
6. Angelo’s Pizza — Lakewood (Cleveland Area)
If you ask any Cleveland native about great pizza, Angelo’s Pizza will be one of the first names mentioned. This Lakewood landmark has been serving mouthwatering pies since 1981 and is often ranked among the best in Northeast Ohio.
Signature deep-dish and traditional crust options.
Homemade sauce that’s slightly sweet but perfectly balanced.
Generous toppings — you’ll never get a “bare” slice.
The “Meat Lovers Deluxe.”
The “Spinach & Feta White Pizza” for something lighter.
- Tip: Expect a wait on weekends — it’s that popular. But trust me, it’s worth every minute.
- Address: 13715 Madison Ave, Lakewood, OH
- Website: angeloslakewood.com
7. Gionino’s Pizzeria — Statewide (Multiple Locations)
Ohioans know Gionino’s Pizzeria as a local legend. With more than 40 locations across the state, it’s a trusted go-to for families craving that perfect mix of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and melty cheese.
Over 30 years of Ohio pizza tradition.
Famous for their “Italiano Fried Chicken” combo — yes, pizza and chicken!
Consistent quality no matter which city you visit.
The “Italiano Pizza” (pepperoni, sausage, onion, banana peppers).
Their fried chicken dinner — seriously, it’s a local favorite pairing.
- Fun fact: They started in Tallmadge, Ohio, back in 1989 and remain family-owned.
- Address: Multiple Ohio locations
- Website: gioninos.com
8. Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza — Columbus (OSU Campus Area)
Adriatico’s is an absolute institution near The Ohio State University. It’s where generations of students, locals, and travelers have gone for huge, cheesy slices since 1986.
Thick, chewy crust with plenty of sauce and cheese.
Huge New York–style slices — perfect for sharing.
Late-night hours make it the go-to after concerts or games.
The “Square Sicilian Pizza” — crispy edges, thick dough.
Pepperoni with extra cheese (their cheese pull is legendary).
- Tip: Parking can be tricky near campus — grab a spot early or order online for pickup.
- Address: 1618 Neil Ave, Columbus, OH
9. Two Cousin’s Pizza — Mansfield
For those exploring smaller towns, Two Cousin’s Pizza in Mansfield is a hidden gem that feels like home. Family-owned and community-focused, it’s all about generous portions and affordable comfort food.
Friendly, old-school atmosphere — no fancy gimmicks here.
Fresh dough made daily and baked to golden perfection.
Excellent prices and large family-sized pizzas.
The “Supreme” with extra cheese.
Try their breadsticks — locals say they’re some of the best in the area.
- Good to know: They also offer gluten-free crust and dairy-free cheese on request.
- Address: 103 N Main St, Mansfield, OH
- Website: twocousinspizzamansfield.com
10. Luigi’s Restaurant — Akron
You can’t talk about Ohio pizza without mentioning Luigi’s Restaurant — one of Akron’s most iconic spots since 1949. This old-school Italian joint serves classic pizza, pasta, and salads that have barely changed in 70+ years.
Legendary cheese-topped salad and traditional pizzas.
A nostalgic, dimly lit atmosphere that feels like stepping back in time.
Cash-only — they’ve stayed true to their roots.
The “Cheese Pizza” (simple, perfect, timeless).
Pair it with their signature salad and homemade dressing.
- Tip: Bring cash — they don’t accept cards, and there’s usually a line out the door on weekends.
- Address: 105 N Main St, Akron, OH
11. Harvest Pizzeria — Columbus & Beyond
Harvest Pizzeria started as a small neighborhood joint in Columbus and has now expanded across the state. They’re known for their farm-to-table philosophy and locally sourced ingredients — a fresh twist on traditional pizza.
Handmade dough with a perfect wood-fired finish.
Locally sourced toppings like Ohio goat cheese, arugula, and spicy sausage.
Cozy, rustic vibes and craft cocktails to match.
The “Spicy Yuma” (chipotle, chorizo, roasted corn).
“Pineapple + Jalapeño” if you like a sweet-heat combo.
- Address: Multiple locations in Columbus, Dublin & Bexley
- Website: harvestpizzeria.com
12. Dewey’s Pizza — Cincinnati & Statewide
Dewey’s Pizza has become an Ohio staple since opening in 1998. Their artisan pizzas, friendly staff, and open-kitchen setup make dining there an experience, not just a meal.
Consistent quality across all locations.
Gourmet flavor combinations and fresh dough made daily.
Modern, family-friendly dining spaces.
“Edgar Allan Poe” (mozzarella, fontina, mushrooms, kalamata olives, roasted garlic).
“Ryan’s Inferno” for buffalo chicken lovers.
- Address: Dozens of Ohio locations (Cincinnati, Columbus, Dayton)
Website: deweyspizza.com
13. Natalie’s Coal-Fired Pizza — Worthington
Tucked just north of Columbus, Natalie’s Coal-Fired Pizza combines great pizza with live music — a true hidden gem. It’s part jazz club, part restaurant, and fully unforgettable.
Coal-fired crust — crispy on the outside, chewy inside.
Locally sourced ingredients and seasonal specials.
Live music most nights — jazz, blues, or acoustic sets.
“Arugula & Prosciutto” pizza.
Pair with their house-made sangria.
- Address: 5601 N High St, Worthington, OH
14. Goodfella’s Pizzeria — Athens
College town favorite Goodfella’s Pizzeria in Athens serves up giant New York-style slices that keep Ohio University students (and locals) coming back long after graduation.
Oversized slices that hang off your plate.
Laid-back atmosphere perfect for groups or late-night eats.
Affordable pricing for huge portions.
The “Buffalo Chicken Pizza.”
The “Goodfella Supreme” for a flavor-packed bite.
- Address: 6 W Union St, Athens, OH
15. Carle’s Bratwurst & Pizza — Bucyrus
You might not expect to find great pizza at a bratwurst restaurant, but Carle’s proves otherwise. Famous for its German-American recipes, this family-run spot has quietly become a local pizza favorite in Bucyrus.
Freshly baked crust with a buttery finish.
Toppings made from their in-house meats and sausages.
A truly unique “Midwest comfort” experience.
The “Bratwurst Pizza” — yes, it’s exactly what it sounds like.
Add sauerkraut and mustard drizzle for a one-of-a-kind Ohio flavor.
- Address: 1210 E Mansfield St, Bucyrus, OH
Final Thoughts
From coal-fired creativity to generations-old family recipes, Ohio’s pizza scene is an adventure waiting to be tasted. Whether you’re on a food-lover’s road trip or just exploring your local town, each of these pizzerias delivers a story baked into every bite.
And the best part? You can travel across Ohio and never eat the same kind of pizza twice. That’s the beauty of local flavor — and it’s what keeps both locals and tourists coming back for more.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What’s the most popular pizza chain in Ohio?
Dewey’s Pizza and Gionino’s Pizzeria are two local chains that dominate the Ohio scene.
2. Are there any coal-fired pizza spots in Ohio?
Yes — Natalie’s Coal-Fired Pizza in Worthington is the most popular and unique one.
3. Which pizza spot offers live music?
Natalie’s in Worthington regularly hosts live bands and artists.
4. Where can tourists try “Ohio-only” pizza styles?
Harvest Pizzeria and Luigi’s both use local ingredients and traditional techniques unique to the region.
5. What’s the most underrated pizza place in Ohio?
Carle’s Bratwurst & Pizza — it’s unexpected, authentic, and totally delicious.
