There’s something about a lobster roll in Massachusetts that just hits differently—maybe it’s the ocean breeze, the buttery toasted buns, or the fact that you’re tasting the freshest Atlantic lobster imaginable. As someone who’s tried lobster rolls across the state—from roadside shacks to upscale coastal eateries—I’ve rounded up the top 15 lobster rolls in Massachusetts you absolutely have to try in 2025.
Whether you like yours warm with butter (Connecticut-style) or chilled with mayo (New England-style), these spots serve up unforgettable bites that locals swear by and visitors travel for.
1. Neptune Oyster – Boston, MA
📍 North End, Boston
💰 Market Price (Usually around $38)
Neptune Oyster is legendary. Tucked inside Boston’s North End, this tiny seafood haven has a cult following—and for good reason. Their hot buttered lobster roll is a game-changer: succulent, sweet chunks of fresh lobster piled high on a perfectly grilled brioche bun. No fillers. No fluff. Just rich, buttery lobster in all its glory.
Despite the price, it’s consistently rated one of the best in the country, and the wait is almost always worth it (or you can try to beat the lunch rush).
2. The Lobster Pool – Rockport, MA
📍 Cape Ann, Rockport
💰 Around $28
Overlooking the rocky coast of Cape Ann, The Lobster Pool is where locals go when they want a classic, no-frills lobster roll with a million-dollar view. Their cold lobster roll is lightly tossed in mayo and served on a grilled New England hot dog bun. Simple, fresh, and perfect for enjoying while watching the sunset.
Pro tip: Bring a jacket. Even in summer, the ocean breeze can get chilly—but it makes that warm roll hit even harder.
3. Sesuit Harbor Café – Dennis, MA (Cape Cod)
📍 Cape Cod, Dennis
💰 Around $27
Ask any Cape Cod local where to get the best lobster roll, and Sesuit Harbor Café is almost always the answer. Hidden in the back of a marina, this spot is famous for overflowing lobster rolls served cold with just a touch of mayo—and a lemon wedge if you like a little zing.
The best part? You get to eat at picnic tables right by the water while boats drift by. It’s pure New England charm, and it doesn’t get more Cape Cod than this.
4. Roy Moore Lobster Co. – Rockport, MA
📍 Downtown Rockport
💰 Around $24
A true hidden gem, Roy Moore Lobster Co. feels like stepping back in time. It’s a tiny shack where they steam lobsters right in front of you. Their lobster roll is chock-full of claw and knuckle meat, chilled, lightly dressed in mayo, and packed into a toasted bun.
Grab a roll, walk a few steps down to Bearskin Neck, and eat it by the harbor. It’s the kind of local experience tourists dream of but rarely find.
5. James Hook & Co. – Boston, MA
📍 Fort Point Channel, Boston
💰 Small $19, Large $35
Family-owned since 1925, James Hook & Co. is a Boston staple. Their waterfront location is hard to miss, and so is their lobster roll. You can choose between a small or large, but let’s be real—go big or go home.
Served cold, the lobster meat is ultra-fresh and lightly dressed to let the flavor shine. They even ship nationwide if you end up craving another after your trip.
6. The Clam Shack – Falmouth, MA
📍 Falmouth Harbor, Cape Cod
💰 Around $26
🌐 Visit The Clam Shack Falmouth
The Clam Shack in Falmouth may look like a humble seafood stand, but don’t let that fool you—their lobster roll is top-tier. It’s served warm with butter or cold with mayo, and each one is piled with claw and tail meat that’s as fresh as it gets. The roll is perfectly grilled and slightly sweet, letting the lobster shine without overpowering sauces.
It’s a casual place, so grab a bench outside and enjoy your roll with a side of ocean breeze.
7. Woodman’s of Essex – Essex, MA
📍 Essex, North Shore
💰 Around $29
A true institution, Woodman’s of Essex has been serving up seafood since 1914—and their lobster roll is a testament to tradition. You’ll get a generous helping of hand-picked lobster meat on a classic grilled bun with just a touch of mayo. It’s simple, delicious, and served in a relaxed setting that feels more like a family picnic than a restaurant.
Bonus: It’s also the birthplace of the fried clam. So if you’re feeling extra hungry, make it a combo.
8. Alive & Kicking Lobsters – Cambridge, MA
📍 Cambridge, just outside Boston
💰 Around $23
🌐 Visit Alive & Kicking Lobsters
Alive & Kicking Lobsters is known for one thing: their unique “lobster sandwich.” It’s not a traditional roll—it’s served between two thick slices of buttery toasted bread. But trust me, it’s absolutely incredible.
They use freshly steamed lobster, no frills, no filler, and it’s always made to order. This spot is ultra-casual and only open seasonally, but it’s a hidden favorite among in-the-know locals.
9. Captain Scott’s – New Bedford, MA
📍 New Bedford Waterfront
💰 Around $22
🌐 Captain Scott’s Facebook Page
Captain Scott’s may not get the buzz of Boston or Cape Cod spots, but don’t sleep on this New Bedford gem. Their lobster roll is overflowing with meat, and the roll is buttery, soft, and golden-toasted to perfection.
It’s a local favorite for lunch breaks and summer nights. Bonus points: the seafood here is incredibly affordable for the portion size, and you get that authentic harbor-town feel without tourist crowds.
10. Lobster Trap – Bourne, MA
📍 Bourne, near the Cape Cod Canal
💰 Around $28
Known for its fresh seafood and chill atmosphere, The Lobster Trap delivers one of the most balanced lobster rolls in the state. Choose your style (hot buttered or cold with mayo), and you’ll get a generous helping of fresh knuckle and claw meat on a perfectly toasted roll.
There’s a raw bar, outdoor seating by the water, and even live music on summer weekends. It’s a great stop if you’re entering or leaving the Cape and want to avoid the traffic madness of Route 6.
11. Bostwick’s Chowder House – East Hampton, MA (Seasonal Pop-Up)
📍 East Hampton (Western MA Seasonal Pop-Up Location)
💰 Around $26
🌐 Check Their Instagram for Seasonal Location Info
While the original Bostwick’s Chowder House is famous on the East End of Long Island, in 2025, they’ve launched a seasonal pop-up in Western Massachusetts that’s drawing massive attention. Their lobster roll is served hot or cold, overflowing with meat, and has a rich buttery flavor that doesn’t overpower the freshness of the lobster.
This is a limited-edition foodie find, and if you’re near the Berkshires this summer, it’s 100% worth the detour.
12. Tony’s Clam Shop – Quincy, MA
📍 Wollaston Beach, Quincy
💰 Around $24
Overlooking Wollaston Beach, Tony’s Clam Shop is a beloved South Shore institution. Their lobster roll is hefty, lightly dressed in mayo, and served with house-cut fries or onion rings. It’s no-frills, no fuss, and always satisfying.
Locals love it for the classic seafood shack vibes, plus the option to enjoy your meal with ocean views and a salty breeze.
13. Jake’s Seafood – Hull, MA
📍 Nantasket Beach, Hull
💰 Around $27
Jake’s Seafood is one of the best-kept secrets on the South Shore. Their lobster roll is stacked high with fresh meat, served warm or cold, and comes on a toasted roll with lemon butter or light mayo.
What makes it special? The restaurant has been family-run since the 1940s and sources lobster directly from local fishermen. If you’re walking along Nantasket Beach, Jake’s is the place to stop.
14. Legal Sea Foods – Multiple Locations (Including Logan Airport)
📍 Multiple locations including Boston, Cambridge, and the airport
💰 Around $30 (varies by location)
While Legal Sea Foods is a bit more commercial, it deserves a spot on this list for one reason: consistency. You’ll get a fresh, well-portioned lobster roll with the option of hot butter or chilled mayo style, even if you’re just passing through Logan Airport.
Perfect for travelers craving one last New England taste before departure.
15. The Lobster Shanty – Salem, MA
📍 Historic Downtown Salem
💰 Around $25
If you want a lobster roll with a side of quirky charm and a little witch city magic, The Lobster Shanty is it. Known for its laid-back atmosphere and outdoor seating, the roll here is cold-style, generous in portion, and often paired with one of their locally famous cocktails.
It’s a great stop if you’re touring Salem’s historic sites and want a break from the crowds.
Final Thoughts: What Makes a Great Lobster Roll in Massachusetts?
When it comes to lobster rolls in Massachusetts, freshness is king. The best ones use daily-caught local lobster, minimal fillers, and a soft yet crisp bun. Whether you’re road-tripping through Cape Cod or spending a weekend in Boston, these five spots will give you a true taste of the Bay State.
Here’s a quick pro tip: If you want to avoid long lines, aim for a weekday lunch visit—and always check if the spot is seasonal (some close in the winter).
Related Post you may like:
I am Sabiq Rasel is an Entrepreneur and broadcaster. I believe that every sip of coffee holds the potential for a moment of inspiration, creativity, and every cup tells a story.
