When people think of lobster rolls, Illinois probably isn’t the first state that comes to mind. But in 2025, you don’t have to travel to Maine or Boston to get your fix. A handful of restaurants around Illinois are serving up lobster rolls that are fresh, flavorful, and worth every bite. I’ve put together this list of the best lobster rolls in Illinois so you know exactly where to go when the craving hits.
Don’s Dock is a local seafood landmark in Des Plaines that has been around for decades. While it’s famous for fried fish and shrimp dinners, their lobster roll has gained a quiet reputation among seafood lovers. The roll is simple — chunks of sweet lobster meat, lightly dressed with mayo or butter, and served on a toasted bun.
Fresh lobster, not overpowered by heavy sauces.
Laid-back, old-school seafood shack vibes.
Affordable compared to big-city restaurants.
- Tip: Go during lunch hours to avoid crowds and try pairing it with their clam chowder.
2. Luke’s Lobster – Chicago, IL
Luke’s Lobster is a well-known East Coast chain that has made its way to Chicago. Their lobster rolls are the real deal, made with sustainably sourced Maine lobster. Each roll is lightly dressed with mayo, a squeeze of lemon, and a touch of seasoning in a split-top New England bun.
- Visit their Chicago location here: Luke’s Lobster – City Hall.
Authentic New England–style lobster roll.
Consistent quality every time.
They offer different portion sizes, including jumbo rolls if you’re extra hungry.
- Tip: Ask about seasonal specials — sometimes they offer unique twists on the classic roll.
3. Shaw’s Crab House – Chicago, IL
Shaw’s Crab House is a Chicago classic for anyone who loves seafood. While their oysters and crab legs get most of the attention, their lobster roll is one of the best in the city. Served with buttered brioche and plenty of lobster meat, it’s rich and satisfying.
- Explore their menu at Shaw’s Crab House.
High-quality lobster in a fine-dining setting.
Great place if you want more than just a roll — full seafood menu available.
Perfect for date nights or celebrations.
- Tip: Pair it with their famous oysters or crab cakes for the full experience.
4. Brown Bag Seafood Co. – Multiple Locations (Chicago Area)
Brown Bag Seafood Co. keeps things casual and fun. Their lobster roll is served in a more modern style, with options to customize your order. You can have it warm with butter or cold with light mayo. Their focus on sustainable seafood makes this a great option for eco-conscious diners.
- See more at Brown Bag Seafood.
Customizable lobster rolls.
Quick-service style — great for lunch or takeout.
Several locations around Chicago make it convenient.
- Tip: Try their lobster tater tots if you’re looking for something different on the side.
5. Half Shell – Chicago, IL
Half Shell is a casual neighborhood spot in Chicago known for its crab legs, but don’t overlook their lobster roll. It’s not fancy, but it’s packed with flavor and served in generous portions.
- Check out their info here: Half Shell Chicago.
Generous serving of lobster for the price.
Cozy, laid-back atmosphere.
A local favorite for seafood lovers.
- Tip: This place can get busy on weekends, so go early if you don’t want to wait.
6. Quality Crab & Oyster Bah – Chicago, IL
This Lettuce Entertain You restaurant in Lincoln Park delivers a seafood experience that rivals East Coast spots. Their lobster roll is packed with fresh meat and served on a buttery roll with just the right seasoning.
- Menu: Quality Crab & Oyster Bah
Known for high-quality seafood.
Fun, lively atmosphere.
Great raw bar options to pair with your roll.
- Tip: Pair your lobster roll with their famous crab legs or oysters for a well-rounded meal.
7. The Hampton Social – Multiple Chicago Locations
If you’re looking for a trendy spot with a coastal vibe, The Hampton Social is your place. Their lobster roll is Instagram-worthy and comes with a choice of warm butter or light mayo dressing.
- Visit: The Hampton Social
Chic, beachy decor perfect for social outings.
High-quality lobster roll with fresh presentation.
Multiple Chicago locations for convenience.
- Tip: Go for brunch — their lobster roll pairs beautifully with a mimosa or frosé.
8. GT Fish & Oyster – Chicago, IL
A polished seafood restaurant in River North, GT Fish & Oyster takes the lobster roll seriously. Their version uses buttery brioche and sweet lobster chunks with a hint of lemon.
- Explore: GT Fish & Oyster
Upscale dining experience.
Creative seafood menu beyond lobster rolls.
Ideal for date nights or business dinners.
- Tip: Order small plates like their fish tacos along with the roll for variety.
9. The Crab Cellar – Chicago, IL
Known for its “all-you-can-eat crab” experience, The Crab Cellar also offers a hearty lobster roll that’s packed with flavor. It’s a hidden gem if you’re already a fan of their crab feasts.
Lobster roll portions are generous.
Fun, casual, group-friendly spot.
Great if you love seafood variety.
- Tip: Make a reservation — this place fills up fast, especially on weekends.
10. Ocean Prime – Chicago, IL
Ocean Prime is a high-end seafood and steakhouse chain, and their lobster roll reflects that upscale vibe. Served with top-quality lobster and a rich, buttery bun, it’s as luxurious as it gets in Illinois.
- Menu: Ocean Prime Chicago
Elegant atmosphere with excellent service.
High-end lobster roll for special occasions.
Extensive wine and cocktail list to pair with.
- Tip: Perfect for anniversaries or celebrations — order the lobster roll as part of a multi-course seafood dinner.
Final Thoughts
You don’t need to travel to New England to enjoy a great lobster roll. Illinois has plenty of spots — from casual seafood shacks to upscale restaurants — that know how to do it right. Whether you’re in Chicago or the suburbs, you can find a lobster roll that hits the spot.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- Q: Where can I find the most authentic lobster roll in Illinois?
Luke’s Lobster offers a true New England–style roll with Maine lobster. - Q: Which lobster roll is most affordable?
Don’s Dock in Des Plaines gives you great value for fresh lobster without downtown Chicago prices. - Q: Are there lobster rolls outside of Chicago?
Yes! Don’s Dock in Des Plaines is a great suburban option.
