There’s something timeless about a scoop of ice cream that instantly makes you feel like a kid again. Whether you’re exploring Ohio on a summer road trip or just craving a sweet weekend treat, the state is full of ice cream shops that are worth every calorie. After checking reviews, feedback from locals, and trying a few myself, here are 15 Ohio ice cream spots that truly stand out for flavor, atmosphere, and consistency.
1. Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams — Columbus, OH
Jeni’s has become a household name not just in Ohio but across the U.S., and for good reason. Founded in Columbus, this shop makes ice cream that’s as creative as it is delicious — with unique, handcrafted flavors like Brambleberry Crisp, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, and Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks.
Highlights:
Named one of the best ice cream shops in Ohio for 2025 by Eat This, Not That!
Locally sourced ingredients and small-batch production ensure quality.
The atmosphere is bright, modern, and perfect for photos.
- Website: Visit Jeni’s Splendid Ice Creams
- Tip: Always grab a couple of seasonal flavors — Jeni’s constantly experiments with new combinations that rarely disappoint.
2. Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream — Youngstown, OH
A true Ohio classic, Handel’s has been serving handcrafted ice cream since 1945. What makes them legendary is their old-fashioned style — creamy texture, generous portions, and over 100 rotating flavors made fresh daily.
Ranked among the top ice cream chains in America by USA Today.
Every store makes its ice cream on-site daily for the freshest taste.
Known for signature flavors like Chocolate Pecan, Graham Central Station, and Blueberry Cheesecake.
- Website: Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream
- Tip: Order a four-scoop sampler to taste multiple flavors — trust me, you’ll want to.
3. Aglamesis Bro’s Ice Cream & Chocolates — Cincinnati, OH
Step back in time at Aglamesis Bro’s, a family-owned Cincinnati landmark that’s been around since 1908. This vintage parlor blends old-school charm with incredible homemade ice cream and hand-dipped chocolates.
The interior looks straight out of a 1950s movie — marble tables, pink décor, and a nostalgic feel.
Their Pineapple Ice, French Vanilla, and Double Chocolate are must-tries.
They make their own chocolates and candies, perfect for gift boxes.
- Website: Aglamesis Bro’s Ice Cream & Chocolates
- Tip: Visit during the holidays — their peppermint stick ice cream is a local favorite.
4. Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream — Cleveland, OH
Mitchell’s is a Cleveland favorite known for sustainability, creativity, and deep flavor. Each batch is made with hormone-free dairy and locally sourced ingredients, and their Ohio City flagship location lets you see the ice cream being made through a glass window.
Flavors range from Caramel Fudge Brownie to Wildberry Crumble.
Vegan and dairy-free options available.
Recognized by Cleveland Magazine as one of the best ice cream shops in Northeast Ohio.
- Website: Mitchell’s Homemade Ice Cream
- Tip: Go early on weekends — this shop gets packed fast, especially in summer evenings.
5. Young’s Jersey Dairy — Yellow Springs, OH
Located just outside Dayton, Young’s Jersey Dairy is more than an ice cream shop — it’s a family destination. You can enjoy farm-fresh ice cream made from their own Jersey cows, pet the animals, and even play mini-golf or hit the batting cages.
Freshly made ice cream with rich dairy flavor straight from the farm.
Signature flavor: Cow Patty (chocolate ice cream with chocolate chips and nuts).
Great stop for families or weekend travelers.
- Website: Young’s Jersey Dairy
- Tip: Visit in spring or fall for outdoor events — and don’t skip their homemade cheese curds!
6. Graeter’s Ice Cream — Cincinnati, OH
If there’s one name synonymous with Ohio ice cream history, it’s Graeter’s. Founded in 1870, it’s one of the oldest family-run ice cream companies in America. Their signature French Pot process makes the ice cream incredibly dense, smooth, and rich — a texture you can’t find anywhere else.
Famous for Black Raspberry Chocolate Chip, a true Ohio classic.
Handmade in small batches using traditional techniques.
Available statewide and even shipped nationwide.
- Website: Graeter’s Ice Cream
- Tip: Always get a scoop with chocolate chips — they’re not chips at all but thick, crunchy chocolate slabs.
7. Johnson’s Real Ice Cream — Bexley, OH
Family-owned since 1950, Johnson’s Real Ice Cream is a Columbus institution that still makes ice cream the old-fashioned way — rich, creamy, and full of flavor. Their friendly service and local vibe make it a neighborhood favorite.
Crowd favorites: Buckeye Fever, Cookies & Cream, and Butter Pecan.
Offers sundaes, shakes, and vegan-friendly options.
Family-owned for four generations — rooted in Ohio tradition.
- Website: Johnson’s Real Ice Cream
- Tip: Try their Bexley Sundae — it’s indulgent but worth every bite.
8. Honey Hut Ice Cream — Cleveland, OH
Since 1974, Honey Hut has been a Cleveland staple known for its natural ingredients and signature honey-based recipes. Every flavor is made with care — no artificial sweeteners or syrups, just real cream and honey for sweetness.
Signature flavors: Honey Pecan, Chocolate Peanut Butter, and Banana.
Consistently rated one of Cleveland’s best ice cream spots by locals.
Family-run and community-loved for 50+ years.
- Tip: Order the Honey Pecan Sundae — it’s their most famous item and the perfect balance of sweet and nutty.
9. Toft Dairy Ice Cream Parlor — Sandusky, OH
Toft Dairy, Ohio’s oldest dairy (founded in 1900), is located near Cedar Point — making it a perfect stop for theme park visitors. Their ice cream is made from locally sourced milk and loaded with mix-ins, from fudge ribbons to peanut butter cups.
Try Lake Erie Cookie Island Monster — a fun, colorful favorite.
Known for oversized scoops and creamy texture.
Local ingredients and family heritage for over 120 years.
- Website: Toft Dairy Ice Cream Parlor
- Tip: Stop by after a day at Cedar Point — the line moves fast, and you’ll cool off in the sweetest way possible.
10. Whit’s Frozen Custard — Granville, OH
Technically frozen custard, but absolutely worth including. Whit’s Frozen Custard has become an Ohio treasure, now with dozens of locations across the state. Each batch is made fresh daily, and the texture is so smooth it practically melts on contact.
Famous for Whitties — custom custard sandwiches between chocolate chip cookies.
Weekly flavor rotations and endless topping options.
Clean, friendly shops with a small-town charm.
- Tip: Grab the Whittie to-go pack — it’s perfect for sharing (or not sharing at all).
11. Pav’s Creamery — Akron, OH
If you love rich, custard-style ice cream and creative sundaes, Pav’s Creamery is a must-visit. This Akron staple has been serving locals since 1969 and is known for its ultra-creamy texture, generous toppings, and fun flavor combinations.
Try the Buckeye Sundae or Cookie Monster.
They also serve boozy milkshakes for adults.
Friendly staff and a cozy retro vibe.
- Tip: Don’t skip the Fried Ice Cream Sundae — it’s a hidden gem on their menu.
12. Hartzler Family Dairy — Wooster, OH
For those who prefer farm-fresh ice cream made the traditional way, Hartzler Family Dairy delivers. Their ice cream is made with milk from grass-fed cows — no hormones, no artificial ingredients, just pure flavor.
Simple, natural ingredients with a creamy, authentic taste.
Best known for Homemade Vanilla and Chocolate Peanut Butter.
A peaceful, family-friendly farm atmosphere.
- Tip: Visit during summer to watch farm tours and enjoy a scoop right where the milk comes from!
13. Chill Artisan Ice Cream — Cleveland, OH
For the true ice cream artist at heart, Chill Artisan Ice Cream is all about creative, chef-inspired flavors. Their small-batch ice creams are made with local Ohio ingredients and change seasonally.
Flavors like Roasted Strawberry Balsamic and Ohio Bourbon Pecan.
Gluten-free and dairy-free options available.
Modern, minimalist shop design perfect for Instagram photos.
- Tip: Ask for their “flight of scoops” — a sampler platter that lets you try multiple flavors at once.
14. Dietsch Brothers Fine Chocolates & Ice Cream — Findlay, OH
A beloved Findlay institution since 1937, Dietsch Brothers is known for both handmade chocolates and creamy, rich ice cream. Their quality and service have earned them multiple “Best in Ohio” awards.
Fan favorites include Chocolate Marshmallow and Butter Pecan.
Offers gourmet chocolates and candies alongside ice cream.
Nostalgic 1940s-style parlor with a welcoming vibe.
- Website: Dietsch Brothers
- Tip: Pair a scoop of Vanilla Bean with one of their homemade chocolate truffles — a match made in dessert heaven.
15. Milk & Honey Ice Cream — Chillicothe, OH
Milk & Honey is a small-town favorite that blends homemade ice cream with local charm. They focus on freshness, community, and family values — serving generous scoops that keep people coming back.
Known for Peanut Butter Swirl and Black Raspberry Chip.
Cozy shop perfect for a relaxing afternoon.
Locally sourced dairy from Ohio farms.
- Tip: Try their ice cream pies — a local secret that’s perfect for parties or road trips.
Final Thoughts
Ohio is full of sweet surprises, and these 15 ice cream shops prove it. From heritage creameries that have been serving for over a century to new artisanal scoop shops, the state’s ice cream culture is thriving in 2025. Whether you’re on a family road trip or a solo foodie adventure, there’s a cone waiting with your name on it somewhere in the Buckeye State.
So, the next time someone asks where to find the best ice cream in Ohio — send them this list.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. What’s the most unique ice cream flavor in Ohio?
Jeni’s Goat Cheese with Red Cherries and Chill Artisan’s Roasted Strawberry Balsamic are both must-tries.
2. Which ice cream shops have the best sundaes?
Pav’s Creamery and Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream are famous for creative sundaes and generous toppings.
3. Are any of these shops locally owned?
Yes — nearly all of them are Ohio-based family businesses or small-batch local shops.
4. Which one is best for kids?
Young’s Jersey Dairy and Johnson’s Real Ice Cream are especially family-friendly.
5. Where can I find artisan-style ice cream in Ohio?
Jeni’s, Chill Artisan, and Mitchell’s all specialize in handcrafted, gourmet ice cream experiences.
