If you thought the best lobster rolls could only be found along the New England coast, think again. Pennsylvania’s food scene has grown in surprising ways — and yes, that includes some truly mouth-watering lobster rolls. From cozy coastal-themed cafés to upscale seafood bars, here are the 10 best lobster roll spots in Pennsylvania for 2025 you absolutely need to try.
If you want a taste that feels straight out of Maine, Mason’s is where you’ll find it. Their rolls are packed with chunks of tender lobster meat — never shredded — and lightly tossed in butter or mayo, depending on your choice. The classic split-top bun is toasted to perfection, giving it that ideal crunch.
Authentic Maine lobster flown in fresh.
Quick service and coastal-style ambiance.
You can customize between warm (butter) or cold (mayo) rolls.
- Must-Try: The Connecticut Roll — warm lobster with melted butter.
- Location: 3060 Center Valley Pkwy, Center Valley, PA
- Visit Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls
2. La La Lobster – Yardley
A cheerful and modern eatery, La La Lobster is a hit among Bucks County locals. They focus purely on lobster, crab, and shrimp dishes — so you know they take their seafood seriously. Their lobster rolls are generous, with sweet, fresh lobster meat served on a buttery brioche bun.
Bright, coastal décor and friendly staff.
Variety of options — from lobster rolls to lobster bowls and mac & cheese.
Locally owned and operated, supporting Pennsylvania’s small business scene.
- Must-Try: The “La La Original Roll” — simple, buttery, and full of flavor.
- Location: 35 S Main St, Yardley, PA
- Visit La La Lobster
3. Oyster House – Philadelphia
Oyster House in downtown Philly is known for its fresh seafood and vibrant energy. Their lobster roll is a crowd favorite — packed with perfectly cooked lobster meat, a light touch of mayo, and a buttery roll that soaks in all the goodness. It’s the ideal mix of casual and classy dining.
Premium seafood sourced fresh daily.
Excellent wine and craft beer selection.
Great spot for brunch or happy hour seafood platters.
- Must-Try: Their New England-style lobster roll with crispy fries on the side.
- Location: 1516 Sansom St, Philadelphia, PA
- Visit Oyster House
4. Cousins Maine Lobster Truck – Harrisburg
If you prefer a fun, on-the-go lobster experience, this food truck delivers. Cousins Maine Lobster Truck brings authentic, wild-caught lobster rolls straight from Maine to Harrisburg and surrounding towns. Despite being a mobile setup, the quality is outstanding — juicy lobster, toasted roll, and that pure Maine flavor.
Authentic lobster flown in from Maine.
Perfectly seasoned and portioned rolls.
Great for festivals, pop-ups, and local events.
- Must-Try: The Maine Roll (served chilled with light mayo) — their signature.
- Location: Travels around Central PA — check their schedule online
- Check Cousins Maine Lobster Truck Schedule
5. Devon Seafood Grill – Hershey
Located in the heart of Hershey, Devon Seafood Grill offers a more upscale take on the lobster roll. Expect fine dining vibes, professional service, and lobster that tastes like it came straight from the Atlantic. Their mini lobster rolls are a perfect appetizer or main course for seafood lovers.
Elegant atmosphere with a creative seafood menu.
High-quality ingredients and top-notch presentation.
Perfect for date nights or special occasions.
- Must-Try: Mini Lobster Rolls with fresh fries — simple and satisfying.
- Location: 27 W Chocolate Ave, Hershey, PA
- Visit Devon Seafood Grill
6. Luke’s Lobster – Philadelphia
When it comes to authentic Maine-style lobster rolls, Luke’s Lobster is hard to beat. This spot is a staple for East Coast seafood lovers, and the Philadelphia location keeps that coastal feel alive right in the city.
Sustainably sourced lobster straight from Maine.
Perfect balance of butter, seasoning, and chilled lobster chunks.
Cozy, no-frills setup with a strong New England vibe.
- Must-Try: The “Luke’s Trio” — half lobster roll, half crab roll, and half shrimp roll for a true seafood sampler.
- Location: 130 S 17th St, Philadelphia, PA
7. The Boat Yard – Pittsburgh
For those in western Pennsylvania, The Boat Yard offers a refreshing riverside dining experience with a stellar lobster roll. The roll is light yet satisfying — perfectly buttered, lightly seasoned, and brimming with flavor.
Beautiful waterfront view of the Allegheny River.
Excellent craft cocktails and seafood pairings.
Relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere.
- Must-Try: The Warm Lobster Roll with a side of truffle fries and house-made coleslaw.
- Location: 621 Allegheny River Blvd, Verona, PA
8. Kelly’s Seafood – Northeast Philadelphia
Kelly’s has been a go-to seafood stop for locals for decades. Their lobster roll is simple, traditional, and delicious — filled with fresh lobster meat, buttered roll, and just the right amount of mayo.
Old-school seafood joint with generous portions.
Friendly staff and family-owned charm.
Affordable pricing without compromising taste.
- Must-Try: The Classic Maine Lobster Roll — simple and loaded with flavor.
- Location: 9362 Old Bustleton Ave, Philadelphia, PA
9. The Cove – Lake Erie (Erie, PA)
Overlooking beautiful Presque Isle Bay, The Cove serves up one of the most scenic seafood meals in Pennsylvania. Their lobster roll is a local favorite, made with real Maine lobster meat and served on a lightly toasted New England-style bun.
Waterfront dining with an unbeatable view.
Fresh seafood options beyond lobster rolls.
Great place for summer evenings or weekend brunch.
- Must-Try: The Erie Lobster Roll — buttery, juicy, and best enjoyed with a glass of white wine.
- Location: 11 State St, Erie, PA
10. Red Lobster – Multiple Locations (Statewide)
While it’s a national chain, Red Lobster deserves an honorable mention for its consistent quality and accessibility. Their lobster rolls are freshly prepared and perfect for anyone looking to enjoy seafood without a high-end restaurant price tag.
Consistent flavor and portion sizes.
Easy to find in cities like Pittsburgh, Scranton, Allentown, and Lancaster.
Family-friendly with a full seafood menu.
- Must-Try: The “Lobster Lover’s Roll” — generous portion served warm with garlic butter.
- Location: Various cities across Pennsylvania
- Find a Red Lobster Near You
Final Thoughts
From trendy city bistros to cozy coastal-style cafés, Pennsylvania’s lobster roll scene is thriving in 2025. Whether you’re in Philly, Hershey, or Erie, these 10 destinations prove that you don’t need to drive to Maine to enjoy a top-notch lobster roll.
So next time you’re craving buttery, tender lobster tucked into a golden roll — you know exactly where to go!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
1. What type of lobster do these places use?
Most of the top-rated spots use wild-caught Maine lobster, known for its sweet and tender meat.
2. Are there seasonal lobster roll specials in Pennsylvania?
Yes! Many restaurants introduce special versions during summer — like truffle butter or spicy aioli lobster rolls.
3. Can I find gluten-free lobster rolls?
Some spots like La La Lobster and Luke’s Lobster offer gluten-free buns upon request.
4. What’s the average price range?
Expect to spend between $18 and $35, depending on portion size and location.
5. Which lobster roll is the most authentic New England style?
Mason’s Famous Lobster Rolls and Luke’s Lobster stay closest to true New England authenticity.
