Florida isn’t just about beaches and sunshine — it’s also a dream come true for seafood lovers. And when it comes to lobster rolls, the Sunshine State has quietly become a must-visit destination. Whether you prefer the warm, buttery Connecticut style or the chilled, mayo-tossed New England version, these spots serve up some of the freshest and most flavorful lobster rolls you’ll find anywhere. Below are ten of the best places in Florida for lobster rolls in 2025, based on taste, quality, local reputation, and overall dining experience.
If you’re looking for a show-stopping lobster roll, The Nauti Lobstah is the place to go. Chef Mike Rumplik, originally from Rhode Island, brought a slice of New England seafood culture to Central Florida.
Their signature dish? A massive two-foot-long lobster roll filled with two pounds of fresh Maine lobster meat — officially the biggest lobster roll in Florida!
Choose between Connecticut style (warm lobster with melted butter) or New England style (chilled with light mayo).
The lobster meat is perfectly seasoned and tender.
Great for sharing — or tackling solo if you’re really hungry.
- Location: 311 S Forest Ave, Apopka, FL
- Website: The Nauti Lobstah
2. Mystic Lobster Roll Co. – Naples
Mystic Lobster Roll Co. brings a taste of the Northeast to sunny Naples. They pride themselves on using freshly shelled lobster meat delivered daily, with no fillers or shortcuts.
Try their “Maine Roll” for the classic chilled lobster with light mayo, or the “Connecticut Roll” for the warm buttery version.
They also offer specialty rolls like “Tuscan” and “Buffalo Lobster.”
The portions are generous, and the bread is perfectly toasted and buttery.
- Location: 2355 Vanderbilt Beach Rd, Naples, FL
- Website: Mystic Lobster Roll Co. Naples
3. The Lobster Lady Seafood Market & Bistro – Cape Coral
The Lobster Lady is both a seafood market and a full-service restaurant — a favorite among locals for fresh catches and incredible lobster dishes.
The lobster rolls are packed with fresh Maine lobster, lightly dressed in mayo, and served on buttery toasted rolls.
You can even buy lobster meat from the market to take home.
The restaurant also serves lobster bisque, oysters, and other New England classics.
- Location: 1715 Cape Coral Pkwy W, Cape Coral, FL
- Website: Lobster Lady Seafood Market & Bistro
4. Kelly’s Fish House Dining Room – Naples
As one of the oldest seafood restaurants in Naples, Kelly’s Fish House has been serving up fresh catches since 1952. Their lobster roll is a hidden gem that combines local Florida charm with New England flavor.
Fresh lobster meat sourced directly from their own suppliers.
Served with a light lemon mayo on a grilled, buttered roll.
The restaurant sits right on the Gordon River — perfect for a relaxed waterfront meal.
- Location: 1302 5th Ave S, Naples, FL
- Website: Kelly’s Fish House
5. Eaton Street Seafood Market – Key West
If you’re visiting the Keys, Eaton Street Seafood Market is a must-stop for any seafood lover. It’s a small, local spot where freshness is everything.
Their lobster rolls feature Key West spiny lobster, giving a slightly different yet equally delicious taste compared to Maine lobster.
Served with lemon butter and a touch of Old Bay seasoning.
Outdoor seating available — perfect for that island vibe.
- Location: 801 Eaton St, Key West, FL
- Website: Eaton Street Seafood Market
6. Leon’s Lobstah Shack – Tampa
A hidden gem in South Tampa, Leon’s Lobstah Shack is the go-to place for authentic lobster rolls with a Florida twist.
They serve both hot buttered lobster rolls and chilled mayo versions, using only wild-caught lobster meat.
The bread is perfectly toasted — soft on the inside and golden crisp on the outside.
You can enjoy your roll with fries or their creamy New England clam chowder.
- Location: 5314 Interbay Blvd, Tampa, FL
- Menu Link: Leon’s Lobstah Shack
7. Lobstah on a Roll – St. Augustine
Straight from Boston to St. Augustine, Lobstah on a Roll brings the authentic New England seafood shack experience to Florida’s oldest city.
They use premium North Atlantic lobster, served in a buttery, split-top roll.
You can choose from multiple sizes — from the “Little Lobstah” to the “King Lobstah” (packed with half a pound of meat).
The portions are huge, and every bite screams freshness.
- Location: 34 Granada St, St. Augustine, FL
- Website: Lobstah on a Roll St. Augustine
8. The Twisted Lobster – Cape Coral
Locals swear by The Twisted Lobster for its no-frills atmosphere and perfectly balanced lobster rolls. This place focuses on quality ingredients without the fancy price tag.
Their lobster rolls come loaded with chunks of claw and tail meat, lightly dressed in lemon mayo.
Served with crispy fries and coleslaw.
Great family-friendly environment — casual, cozy, and always buzzing.
- Location: 1341 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral, FL
- Website: The Twisted Lobster
9. The Fish Shack – Pompano Beach
This small, local seafood shack is a true hidden treasure on Florida’s east coast. If you want a lobster roll that tastes like it was made in Maine, The Fish Shack won’t disappoint.
They keep things simple: buttered lobster meat on a lightly toasted bun.
The freshness is unbeatable, with seafood delivered daily.
It’s a casual, no-fuss spot — perfect for a quick bite or lunch stop on the beach.
- Location: 2862 NE 17th Ave, Pompano Beach, FL
10. Keys Fisheries – Marathon (Florida Keys)
Located halfway between Key Largo and Key West, Keys Fisheries is famous for its fresh seafood and waterfront dining. Their lobster roll is easily one of the best in the Keys.
They serve Florida spiny lobster instead of Maine lobster — a sweeter, tropical version.
Served warm with butter on a soft toasted bun.
Enjoy your meal with an ocean view while watching boats dock nearby.
- Location: 3502 Gulfview Ave, Marathon, FL
- Website: Keys Fisheries
Final Thoughts
From the Gulf Coast to the Atlantic and all the way down to the Keys, Florida’s lobster roll scene has never been better. Whether you prefer your roll chilled with mayo or warm with butter, these 10 spots deliver the best of both worlds — fresh seafood, local charm, and that unbeatable ocean vibe.
So next time you’re craving lobster, skip the flight to New England — because the best lobster rolls of 2025 are right here in Florida.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1. What’s the best lobster roll in Florida in 2025?
The Nauti Lobstah in Apopka is often rated the best for its giant two-foot lobster roll.
Q2. What’s the difference between Maine and Florida lobster?
Maine lobster has claws and a mild flavor, while Florida’s spiny lobster is clawless and slightly sweeter.
Q3. Are lobster rolls in Florida made with fresh lobster?
Yes, most top spots use fresh or daily-sourced lobster from Maine or local Florida waters.
Q4. What’s the average price of a lobster roll in Florida?
Prices range from $20 to $40, depending on size and location.
Q5. Can I find both warm and cold lobster rolls in Florida?
Absolutely — most restaurants offer both Connecticut (warm butter) and New England (chilled mayo) styles.
